Want to know if this job is worth applying to?
New York, New York, United States
Onsite
Not Available
Wagmo is a new type of pet health company focused on empowering and inspiring responsible pet parenting through top-tier pet benefits provided by employers. From everyday care to rainy-day emergencies, we offer tech-enabled solutions that are optimized for value and flexibility so that our pet parents always feel confident that they are giving their pets the care they deserve.
We solve hard problems all day long but hang out with dogs while we do it. We value authenticity and efficiency and have no time for egos. We prioritize performance over pedigree, compensate fairly, and never take ourselves too seriously. Our values are core to who we are and how we operate. We talk about them all the time. These are not just things posted on a wall. We will interview for them, hold each other accountable to them, and make sure we work with every single person we interact with in a way that's consistent with these values.
Wagmo is looking for a Senior Customer Success Director to own a defined, named book of strategic clients and be the strategic partner their HR, Benefits, and Total Rewards leaders rely on year after year. This is not a reactive support or check-in seat. You are accountable for whether each account's enrollment holds, whether employees keep engaging with Wagmo, and whether the relationship grows into a multi-year, expanding partnership.
You will work as a trusted partner: reading account data, anticipating risk a year before renewal, building the business case for expansion, and influencing the employer's HR, Communications, and executive teams to drive adoption they ultimately control. You will partner closely with Sales on every new-logo handoff and with Implementation on every launch, and you will stay the single accountable owner of the relationship after both are done. If you have built a career turning large, complex accounts into growing, renewing, referenceable partners, we want to talk to you.
Own the post-sale relationship for a named book of enterprise accounts, from onboarding through enrollment, engagement, expansion, and renewal.
Manage post-sale onboarding and partner with Wagmo’s onboarding team to ensure year 1 enrollment success.
Build and maintain a living strategic account plan for every account, refreshed at least quarterly, with owners, risks, goals, and next steps. Conduct quarterly business reviews with clients to review results, risks and engagement/enrollment opportunities.
Serve as the senior, trusted point of contact across the client's HR, Benefits, Total Rewards, Finance, and broker team member. Build multi-threaded relationships no account depends on a single champion
Track and improve employee engagement with the benefit: active-user rate, wellness plan usage, claims activity, app and portal activity, and satisfaction (NPS/CSAT)
Translate account data into a clear value story for the client: employee sentiment, retention and recruiting impact, and benefit ROI
Own renewal and expansion. Hold every account to a NRR target and own the plan to get there: expanded eligible populations, additional coverage tiers, and new product offerings.
Track renewal timelines and account health at least 12 months out
Build an ROI narrative grounded in the account's own enrollment and utilization data, and lead renewal negotiations with the same rigor as a new-business close
Pursue multi-year renewals, and secure references, case studies, and executive sponsors from healthy accounts
Own enrollment % of eligible employees as the leading indicator of account health, and hold each account to its target
Partner with marketing to build and execute on a year-round enrollment and communications calendar with the client's HR/Comms team.
Diagnose low-enrollment risk early and intervene with a specific plan and date
Partner with Implementation on every launch and with Sales on every handoff, while remaining the single accountable owner of the relationship
Represent the client's interests to Product, Marketing, and Finance, and turn recurring account feedback into roadmap and process improvements
Forecast accurately across three concurrent motions: enrollment/engagement health, renewal, and expansion, each on its own evidence
Build and share playbooks (account planning, enrollment, QBR, risk escalation, renewal) that raise the bar for the entire Customer Success team and mentor CSMs on how to run them
8+ years of B2B/SaaS customer success, account management, or client services experience, including 3+ years owning a named strategic book with a retention and expansion number
Proven track record of meeting and exceeding NRR targets on a book of strategic accounts, with examples of how you got there account by account
Demonstrated success driving adoption and enrollment on products where the customer, not you, controls the rollout (benefits, HR tech, or similar employee-facing programs)
Experience working with Fortune 500 or large-enterprise HR, Benefits, and Total Rewards leaders, and with brokers/consultants in a regulated, cyclical buying environment
Strong executive presence: credible with VP and C-level stakeholders, comfortable delivering a hard message with data and a plan
Analytical depth: you build your own account health views from enrollment, claims, and engagement data and can explain what is driving a trend
Proven ability to spot churn and contraction risk 6–12 months out and turn an at-risk account around
Comfort partnering with Sales, Implementation, Marketing, and Product without micromanaging their work or disengaging from the account
Excellent forecasting and operating discipline across renewal, expansion, and enrollment health
Experience with CRM and customer success tooling (e.g., Salesforce, Gainsight, or similar)
Track record of recognition for retention, expansion, or account growth (President's Club, CSM of the Year, or equivalent)
Nice to have: experience in pet insurance, voluntary benefits, or employee benefits administration
Own a book of enterprise relationships where your work shows up directly in enrollment, renewal, and NRR, with a comp plan that rewards it
Shape how some of the largest employers in the country deliver pet benefits, and see the full arc from launch to multi-year renewal
Build the playbooks that define how Customer Success operates as Wagmo scales
Join a rapidly growing, VC-backed startup where ownership, impact, and collaboration drive success
Work in a fast-paced, high-performance environment. This is not a traditional 9-to-5 job, but one that offers flexibility and autonomy in exchange for dedication and impact
Comprehensive health, vision, and dental coverage
HSA/FSA
401(k) retirement planning with employer matching
Unlimited paid time off
Annual company holidays
Additional company-wide recharge days off
12 weeks parental leave for eligible employees
Company paid Wagmo pet wellness and insurance plans
Regular company-wide events and team gatherings
